Pirates’ Ship Still Sinking
Sunday, August 31st, 2008As a baseball fan growing up in Pittsburgh, I watched some pretty awful Pirates teams. The names of the players are probably remembered only by Pirates fans and diehard fans in other cities:
Clem Koshorek, Bobby Del Greco, Tony Bartirome, Eddie O’Brien, Johnny O’Brien, Vic Janowicz, Dino Restelli, Pete Castiglione, George Metkovich, George Strickland, Paul LaPalme, Dick Hall, etc., etc., etc.
As bad as the Pirates of those days were – the 1952 team won 42 games and lost 112 – they did not eclipse the Pirates of these days for consistent futility. These Pirates are days away from matching a major league record for consecutive losing seasons. By losing a few games this week, these Pirates can insure their 16th consecutive losing season, a streak achieved by only one team in major league history.
That would be the cross-state neighbor Philadelphia Phillies, who posted losing records from 1933 through 1948 after staggering through 14 successive losing seasons 1918 through 1931 – 30 losing seasons in 31 years.
Sixty years after the Phillies began their record streak, the Pirates took off on their own path of futility, and, like the Energizer bunny, they’re still going and going and going.
After the first game of their weekend series with Milwaukee, the Pirates had lost 77 games, leaving them five short of securing another losing record. It’s not every team that can pull off such a feat, and it’s not every year that a team can achieve such ignominy. Lest anyone think the Pirates can end the streak next season, do not bet on it. The Pirates have offered no indications this season that better times are on the horizon.
To the contrary, the Pirates have demonstrated an admirable consistency, if consistent losing is to be admired.
Not since Barry Bonds left the Pirates as a free agent after the 1992 season have the Pirates had a winning record. The closest they came was in 1997 when they had a 79-83 record. That season a four-game winning streak brought their record to 78-80, but they lost three of the last four games.
The Pirates blame their futility on their status as a low-revenue team, but they ignore two problems with that excuse: Other low-revenue teams, such as Minnesota and Oakland, not only attain winning records but also reach the playoffs, and the Pirates have been operated poorly through a succession of chief executives and general managers.
They too often have squandered the money they have had to spend on players, and they have traded away promising players before economics forced the moves. Their signing of Pat Meares and Derek Bell epitomizes the former factor and the trade of Aramis Ramirez the latter.
The Pirates chose a curious set of circumstances to try to reverse their fortunes. Bob Nutting, the new board chairman, named Frank Coonelly as club president even though Coonelly never worked in a team’s front office but was a labor lawyer for Major League Baseball.
Coonelly, in turn, named Neal Huntington as general manager even though Huntington had primarily been a scout and talent evaluator, serving in an outside role rather than in an office position. Huntington then named as manager John Russell, a 10-year minor league manager with no major league experience.
Huntington acknowledged that their first season has been disappointing.
“I think from a surface standpoint we have not won enough games,” he said. “Our goal is to put the organization in a position to play meaningful games in September and that is not happening this year.”
Had he expected the Pirates to win more games? “Absolutely,” he said. “The reason we are in this is to win games. Any time you lose, it’s frustrating. We’re not accepting losing as part of the process. We expect our guys to compete every night.”
Off the playing field, on the other hand, Huntington feels the Pirates have made progress. “We talked about changing the culture and we feel good about that,” he said, “but we need to win more games. We feel that is something that is coming.”
The Pirates, the general manager said, “have reconfigured our top 15 prospects with 13 different names as we move forward. Infusion of talent was a goal. We are pleased with where we are.”
But once more the Pirates traded their better players, Xavier Nady and Jason Bay, continuing the policy of exile. One of the best remaining players is Nate McLouth, a 26-year-old outfielder, who was the team’s All-Star representative. He has experienced only three of the first 15 losing seasons.
When the Pirates got close to .500 earlier in the season – 40-44 July 2-3 – McLouth said, “there was a lot of comment made about it. We’ve been there a few times throughout the course of the season. We haven’t been able to get over the hump. Five-hundred isn’t anyone’s goal, but it’s a goal on the way to better things. It sure would be nice to get over that hump.”
Asked if he has heard talk about tying the Phillies’ record, McLouth said, “only by people outside the organization. Nobody has been there for even half the seasons. It’s not really on us, but we certainly would like to end it.”
Even the Phillies ended their 16-year losing streak in 1949. The next year they won the National League pennant and lost to the Yankees in the World Series. The Pirates already have beaten the Yankees in the World Series, and they are not likely to get back there soon.
Mussina Twilight Time
Mike Mussina deserves a lot of credit for his surprisingly good season, but his performance may not be good enough. Good enough for what? Good enough to win 20 games for the first time in his 17-year career.
The Yankees won Mussina’s last two starts, but he didn’t get credit for the victories, staying on hold at 16. That means he has to win four of his remaining five or six scheduled starts to reach 20. He’ll get the extra start if manager Joe Girardi schedules him every fifth day and not every fifth game.
In any event two of his next three starts are expected to be against Tampa Bay, a team he beat twice in the first six weeks of the season but that is a stronger team now as it goes for its first division title.
Mussina has precedent this season for winning four of six starts. He won five successive starts from April 23 through May 14 and more recently won five of seven. On the other hand, he has won only one of his last four starts and three of his last seven.
Questionable Rules Change
Commissioner Bud Selig talks about the good relations between the owners and the players and how that new, improved relationship has benefited baseball economically. Why, then, does he allow his labor executives and the clubs to violate collectively bargained rules and force the union to file a grievance over the violation?
The union has filed a grievance, contending that the commissioner’s office unilaterally and illegally extended the draft signing deadline beyond the negotiated deadline of midnight Aug. 15. At the center of the dispute is the Pittsburgh Pirates’ signing of Pedro Alvarez, a college third baseman, for a $6 million bonus.
The union did not cite Alvarez in its grievance, saying simply it was challenging baseball’s unilateral act. But it just so happens that Scott Boras is Alvarez’s representative, and Boras’ presence usually complicates matters. In this instance, however, Boras doesn’t seem to be culpable.
According to a person familiar with the dispute, talks between the Pirates and Alvarez went to the wire. Four minutes before the deadline the Pirates raised their offer from $5 million to $6 million. At 11:58 p.m. Alvarez made a counteroffer.
The Vanderbilt student subsequently agreed to $6 million after the Pirates told him he had to sign with them or no one. But their agreement clearly came after midnight, and it doesn’t matter if the Pirates say they had permission from the commissioner’s office to go beyond the deadline.
The commissioner’s office can’t act unilaterally. A rule is supposed to be a rule, although the owners weren’t deterred from colluding against free agents in the mid-1980s by the negotiated rules barring concerted action.
This would seem to be a straightforward case for the arbitrator, Shyam Das, but arbitration cases can be unpredictable. Even if Das rules for the union, what will he do about the Alvarez contract? Will he let it stand, will he void it, will he order Alvarez to go back in the draft next June, will he give the Pirates and Alvarez a new period of negotiation?
Union officials have not decided what remedy they will seek from Das in the case that is expected to be heard Sept. 10. At the minimum, they will ask that he order the commissioner’s office not to change rules on its own.
Boras was at the center of a deadline dispute in 1997. That one involved Andy Benes, another Boras client, who was a free agent. Boras negotiated a five-year $30 million contract for the pitcher with St. Louis, but they went beyond a mutually extended deadline.
The agent maintained that the signing occurred before the deadline, but the clubs’ labor arm disputed that view. The union filed a grievance but abandoned it after the first day of hearing.
Make Mine Chocolate Creme
The Tampa Bay Rays have already broken the franchise record for victories, and they have assured themselves of finishing the season with a winning record for the first time. But here’s another way of measuring the Rays’ surprising success:
Dunkin’ Donuts has given out more than 200,000 free doughnuts this season compared with approximately 116,000 last season.
What do doughnuts have to do with the baseball team that has eclipsed the Yankees and the Red Sox this season? This is the second year of a Dunkin’ Donuts promotion that links Rays victories to free doughnuts in the Tampa-St. Petersburg area.
“In 2007 Dunkin’ Donuts started partnering with the baseball team,” said Toby Srebnik, a Dunkin’ spokesman. “It started as ‘Devil Rays win, you win.’ This year it’s ‘Rays win, you win.’ When the team wins a game, either at home or on the road, go into any Dunkin’ store in the Tampa area and you receive one free doughnut. Just say to the cashier that the Rays won and you get a free doughnut.”
Srebnik estimated that the Dunkin’ stores surpassed last year’s total of distributed doughnuts by the end of June. The latest count for this season was computed after Rays win No. 79 – 199,475. That’s an average of 2,525 doughnuts per win. Srebnik said he expected that last year’s total would be doubled by the end of the season.
Srebnik said glazed and chocolate glazed have been the most popular doughnuts requested by Rays fans, but he added, “Every time they beat the Red Sox the Boston crème doughnut was the big doughnut.”








